• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Cheltenham Betting Offers

  • Home
  • Free Bets
  • Meetings
    • New Year’s Day Meeting
    • Festival Trials Day
    • Cheltenham Festival
    • April Meeting
    • Race Night
    • Showcase Meeting
    • November Meeting
    • International Meeting
  • News
  • Articles
    • Stats & Trends

BHA Review Into Bloodstock Industry Shows Unethical Practices

December 20, 2019

unethical practicesThe British Horseracing Authority has released an 83-page review into the practices of the bloodstock industry, which contains a number of recommendations about how things could be improved. Having been commissioned more than two years ago, the report was much-anticipated and has to the bloodstock industry declaring itself ready to ‘adapt and change’.

Whilst the report was scathing of certain aspects of the industry that oversees the buying and selling of bloodstock and horses in the UK, it was also quick to draw attention to the fact that it was a small number of ‘bad apples’ that were giving a bad reputation to others. In general, though, the report was filled with recommendations that aim to help reform the sector.

Why Was The Review Commissioned In The First Place?

british horse racing authorityIn June of 2017 the British Horseracing Authority decided to commission a review into the world of the bloodstock industry. The BHA’s Chief Executive, Nick Rust, wrote in his foreword to the report that the decision to do so was based upon concerns about the ‘perception of unethical practices and experiences’ as well as the ‘number of clear vulnerabilities’ that had been brought to the BHA’s attention.

Justin Felice, who was once the Chief Superintendent for Lancashire Police as well as numerous other important roles within the police, was appointed to lead the report from March 2018. The people in charge of producing the review interviewed in excess of 70 people from across the industry before releasing an interim report in September of last year. It was then shown in full to the BHA’s board in July of this year, with leaks then making it into the press in August.

The Key Findings Of The Report

bad appleAt 83 pages in length it’s fair to say that the review into the buying and selling of horses and bloodstock is pretty close to comprehensive. The result of that is that it’s far too big to look at every aspect of it in detail here, but we can draw attention to certain key findings. Led by former police officer Justin Felice, he made eight suggestions that could transform the way that the industry works.

Those suggestions were based on the two years or so worth of research carried about he and his team. Amongst there findings was the fact that the ‘self-regulating’ that was done in accordance with the Bloodstock Industry Code of Practice from 2009 was barely being done, with many ‘Agents’ breaching the code on a regular basis. The general consensus was that around 5% of Agents were ‘bad apples’, but the rest ‘conducted themselves with integrity’.

Perhaps the most worrying finding from the BHA’s point of view came with point 13 of the review, which said:

“Many of these breaches constitute not only breaches of the Code, but also breaches of related agent/fiduciary legal duties, and in some cases potentially breaches of applicable criminal legislation (including one or more of the Bribery Act 2010, the Fraud Act 2006 and the Criminal Law Act 1977) and the tort of unlawful means conspiracy.”

Unethical & Unlawful Practices

unethicalThese unethical and unlawful practices that the review refers to will be a concern for the British Horseracing Authority, with Agents being the ones highlighted as being problems most commonly. The main areas the BHA will need to watch out for are as follows:

  • Secret Profiteering – Often involving collusion between the likes of the Agent for the purchaser and the vendor.
  • Dual Representation / Commission – Agents would represent both the buyer and the seller without the other’s knowledge, therefore taking commission from both.
  • Luck Money – Agents would demand and then receive money for the sale of a horse.
  • Bidding Up – The practice of bidding up to an agreed amount by people who don’t actually want to buy the horse with the aim of increasing the price that the eventual purchaser has to pay.

What Can Be Done?

regulateKnowing that the industry is rife with problems is one thing, but doing something about them is entirely different. The review refers to the ‘pressing need to change and modernise the culture of the bloodstock industry’, with the hope being that to do so would stop such unlawful conduct becoming ‘normalised’. The problem, however, is that people within the industry are afraid to report any wrongdoing in case they’re then ostracised for doing so. This was backed up by the fact that no complaints have been registered since 2004.

With the self-regulatory model ‘not fit for purpose’ and a ‘lack of integrity in the bloodstock industry’, it’s clear that changes are needed. One suggestion made by Felice and his team was that the BHA should take over as the regulating body for the industry, whilst another recommendation was the formation of a body that industry representatives could communicate with each via, leading to the creation of the Bloodstock Industry Forum earlier this year.

BIF was formed with representatives of the following groups:

  • The Federation of Bloodstock Agents
  • Goffs
  • The National Trainers Federation
  • The Racehorse Owners Association
  • Tattersalls
  • The Thoroughbred Breeders’ Association
  • The Breeze Up Consignors Association
  • The BHA

Licensing Bloodstock Agents

licensedPerhaps one of the key suggestions from the review is the licensing of bloodstock agents in order to limit the potential influence of the ‘bad apples’ that have given the industry such a bad reputation. The hope of the BHA is that anyone acting as an unlicensed agent would then have to face sanctions or even exclusion from the industry as a whole. The Federation of Bloodstock Agents wasn’t convinced that the idea would definitely work, however.

The FBA’s representative, Oliver St Lawrence, said, “it was recognised by all, including the BHA, that the licensing of ‘agents’ in the broadest sense of the word was extremely challenging both logistically and in terms of the international norms applying to buyer participation at bloodstock sales…Nevertheless, the FBA is determined to put in place more rigorous requirements surrounding our membership, including an ‘integrity course’ for all and to establishing membership of the FBA as a recognised and sought after ‘kitemark’ of personal and corporate integrity”.

What It Means For Horse Racing

horses-take-the-bend-at-cheltenham-racecourseThe reality is that the publication of the report means very little for the average racing fan. Unless you are heavily immersed in the importance of bloodstock trading you’re unlikely to give the review more than a passing glance. Yet for those in the industry it is a big deal, putting forward the suggestion that there is ‘clear and compelling evidence of widespread instances of breaches of agency and fiduciary duties’ within the world of bloodstock trading. It will lead to a new Code Of Practice, which will take time to implement.

Obviously the big question for the bloodstock trading industry is whether or not it’s truly willing to implement the changes that the British Horseracing Authority’s review has recommended. The reality is that the report spoke of issues that were ‘ingrained’ in the way it works, so getting rid of these is easier said than done. That the complaints procedure is likely to be ‘independent of the industry bodies’ is likely to be a big help in that regard. It will also be helped by the Racehorse Owners’ Association saying that ‘the protection of owners is paramount’.

Primary Sidebar

Cheltenham Free Bets

Meetings at Cheltenham

  • Cheltenham Festival
    • Champion Day
    • Ladies Day
    • St Patrick’s Thursday
    • Gold Cup Day
  • Festival Trials Day
  • New Year’s Day
  • November Meeting
    • Countryside Day
    • Gold Cup Day
    • November Meeting Sunday
  • Race Night
  • Showcase Meeting
    • The Showcase Friday
    • The Showcase Saturday
  • The April Meeting
    • April Meeting Day One
    • April Meeting Day Two
  • The International Meeting
    • International Friday
    • International Saturday

Race Types

  • Amateur Races
  • Championship Races
  • Conditions Races
  • Cross Country Races
  • Cup Races
  • Fillies' Races
  • Grade 1 Races
  • Grade 2 Races
  • Grade 3 Races
  • Handicap Races
  • Hurdle Races
  • Juvenile Races
  • Listed Races
  • Maiden Races
  • Mares' Races
  • Novices' Races
  • Premier Handicap Races
  • Standard Open Flat Races
  • Steeplechase Races
  • Trial Races
  • Trophy Races
  • Discontinued Races

Latest News

  • Aintree & Cheltenham Amongst Jockey Club Courses To Drop Dress Code
  • What Can Be Done To Combat Race Fixing In Horse Racing?
  • Jockeys Are Struggling With The New Whip Rules
  • Cheltenham Festival Trials Day Likely To Go Ahead As Temperatures Rise This Week
  • BHA Whips Rules Changed At The Last Minute Following A Jockey Backlash

Articles

  • Who Are The BHA?
  • Origins Of Steeplechasing
  • Is Horse Racing Too Traditional? Why Is It So Confusing?
  • Robot Horse Racing
  • Are There More Fatalities On Hard Ground In Horse Racing?
  • Types Of Jump Racing Fences
  • Biggest Comebacks In Horse Racing
  • Difference Between A Hurdle & A Fence In Jump Racing
  • What Are Hurdles & Fences Made From?
  • Why Are Race Distances Measured In Miles, Furlongs & Yards
  • Stag And Hen Do's At Cheltenham
  • Each-Way vs Place Betting: Which Is Better?
  • What Are Final Declarations
  • Does Illegal Horse Racing Still Happen?
  • What Is Pony Racing? How Is It Different To Horse Racing?
  • Ladies At The Races
  • What Do Nose, Head, Neck and Length Mean?
  • What Is A Furlong?
  • When Is A Race Declared Void?
  • False Starts In Horse Racing
  • What Are Official Ratings in Horse Racing?
  • Can You Run A Race With Only One Horse?
  • What Is Point To Point Racing
  • Best Day Of The Cheltenham Festival
  • How Much Does It Cost To Buy and Train a Racehorse?
  • Cheltenham Festival Ticket Types
  • How Much Does Racing Make From The Betting Levy?
  • Are There Less Horse Deaths In Racing Today?
  • Origins Of Jockey Silks In Horse Racing & Rules
  • Can A Jockey Remount A Horse?
  • What Happens If No Horse Wins A Race?
  • Why Do Horses Jump Fences?
  • How High and Far Can A Horse Jump?
  • Use Of The Whip In Horse Racing
  • What Are The Different Types Of Racehorses?
  • Who Sponsors Cheltenham Races
  • How Do Racehorse Owner Syndicates Work?
  • How Much Do Racehorses Weigh?
  • How Does Travelling Affect Racehorse Performance?
  • What PPE Do Jockeys Wear And Why?
  • Can Racehorses Overheat?
  • Benefits Of Owning Race Horses
  • What Is The Top Speed Of A Racehorse?
  • Do Racehorses Have Special Diets & Nutrition?
  • How Are Racehorses Transported & What Are The Rules
  • What Happened To All-Weather Jumps Racing?
  • What Was Tic Tac? The Sign Language For On-Course Bookmakers
  • The Road To Cheltenham
  • Retraining of Racehorses
  • What Happens To Retired Racehorses?
  • Horse Racing Mix-Ups
  • Youngest Jockeys In Horse Racing History
  • What Are Blinkers & Why Do Race Horses Wear Them?
  • How Long Do You Have To Claim A Winning Bet At A Racecourse?
  • Female Jockey Pioneers
  • Oldest Jockeys In Horse Racing History
  • Record Jockey Wins For Cheltenham Festival Races
  • Record Trainer Wins For Cheltenham Festival Races
  • Cheltenham Festival Races Record Horse Wins
  • Biggest Prize Money Races At The Cheltenham Festival
  • The Life Of A Racing Jockey
  • Races With The Most Fences At The Cheltenham Festival
  • How Often Do Mares' Win At The Cheltenham Festival
  • Average Winner Age Cheltenham Festival Races
  • Longest Races At The Cheltenham Festival
  • Cheltenham Festival's Newest Races
  • How Often Does the Favourite Win at the Cheltenham Festival?
  • Average Winner Odds Cheltenham Festival Races
  • Cheltenham Festival Stats & Trends
  • Veganism & Horse Racing
  • Horse Doping In Horse Racing
  • Most Feared Fences In Horse Racing
  • Jockey Injuries
  • How To Become A Jockey
  • Horse Injuries
  • What Is Going In Horse Racing
  • Richest Races In Horse Racing
  • What Is The Starting Price In Racing
  • When Is The Best Time To Bet Ante-Post
  • Impact Of Wetter Winters On UK Jump Racing
  • How Long Do Racehorses Live For?
  • How Much Do Jockeys Weigh?
  • Rules For Naming Race Horses
  • What Is A Dead Heat In Horse Racing?
  • Who Would Win A Race Between A Horse And A Dog?
  • What Makes A Good Jump Stayer?
  • What Is A Stewards Enquiry?
  • Why Are Horses Disqualified and Who Decides?
  • Courses At Cheltenham: Old, New and Cross Country
  • How Are Jump Horses Trained Differently To Flat Horses?
  • Longest Odds Winners In Horse Racing History
  • How Much Money Is Bet At Cheltenham?
  • How Much Is Cheltenham Worth To The Economy?
  • Top 5 Cheltenham Festival Owners
  • Accessibility At Cheltenham The Cheltenham Festival
  • Cheltenham Festival's Oldest Race Still Running
  • Biggest Female Trainers
  • Celebrity Race Horse Owners
  • Can Jockeys, Trainers & Owners Bet?
  • British vs Irish Trainers And Stables At Cheltenham
  • Things To Do & Places To Visit In Cheltenham
  • The Royal Family And The Cheltenham Festival
  • How Much Does It Cost To Be An On-Course Bookmaker?
  • How Much Money Do Race Horse Owners Make?
  • How Much Money Do Trainers Make?
  • Cheltenham Race Types
  • Cheltenham Hotels & Cheltenham Festival Accommodation
  • Top 5 Cheltenham Festival Trainers
  • Top 5 Cheltenham Festival Jockeys
  • Top 10 Cheltenham Festival Horses
  • How Much Money Do Jockeys Make?
  • Richest Jockeys In Horse Racing History
  • Getting To Cheltenham Racecourse
  • Cheltenham Festival vs Grand National, Which Is Better?
  • Cheltenham Racecourse History
  • Why Is The Cheltenham Festival So Big?
  • Cheltenham Festival History
  • The Prestbury Cup
  • Cheltenham Festival Quiz
  • Cheltenham Festival Top Trainer
  • Cheltenham Festival Top Jockey
  • Cheltenham Racecourse During The War
  • Ante-Post Betting - Risk vs Reward
  • Jump Racing Distances
  • How to Read a Race Card
  • How To Bet On Horse Racing
  • Disqualification, Non-Runners and Rule 4
  • Age, Sex and Weight in Horse Racing
  • History And About National Hunt Racing
  • A-Z Glossary Of Horse Racing Terms
  • Horse Racing News, Statistics & Blogs
  • Live Streaming of Horse Racing
  • Live Betting In Play On Horse Racing
  • Cash Out And Partial Cash Out On Horse Racing
  • Grades and Classes In National Hunt Jump Racing

Offers

  • Acca Offers For Horse Racing
  • Extra Places Each-Way & Enhanced Each Way Terms Cheltenham Festival 2023
  • Horse Racing Loyalty Free Bet Clubs
  • Horse Racing Money Back
  • Best Odds Guaranteed For The Cheltenham Festival
  • Tote and Totepool Betting
  • Lucky Bets and Bonuses For Horse Racing
  • Non-Runner No Bet
  • Free Bets And Bonuses For Winners
  • Best Odds Guaranteed For Horse Racing
  • Faller & Fail To Finish Insurance For Horse Racing

Copyright © 2023 CheltenhamBettingOffers.com | 18+ Gamble Aware | Privacy & Cookie Policy